Between 2019 and 2022, thousands of puppies from Hungary and Slovakia were allegedly smuggled into French territory illegally.
In May 2021, following a several-month preliminary investigation, a major crackdown was simultaneously carried out in five pet shops in Nice and a Parisian establishment.
Over 90 puppies of different breeds were examined and seized. Authorities’ suspicions seem to be confirmed.
Veterinarians appointed found inconsistencies between the age indicated on the documents and the estimated age of the animals.
Some puppies may not have even reached the legal age of two months. Additionally, blood tests revealed shortcomings in vaccination protocols, especially against rabies, raising public health concerns.
No animal cruelty involved: The public ministry represented by Étienne Moreau clarified that the offenses in question primarily revolve around commercial aspects rather than animal abuse.
Only one pet shop manager was prosecuted for mistreatment but will be judged later due to health reasons.
The prosecution requested sentences ranging from 6 to 24 months with fines of 20,000 to 50,000 euros for the 8 accused individuals, with some penalties suspended, and requested the seizure of assets (cash and real estate).
The verdict will be delivered by the criminal court presided over by Marion Menot on Tuesday, May 5th at 1:30 pm.
Amid Covid-19: The only Hungarian trader responding to the allegations admitted to introducing only a few unvaccinated puppies over a short period, particularly during the high-demand Covid-19 era.
Pet shop managers, who were once clients and are now co-defendants, received regular deliveries of about 15 puppies each time. Were they aware of these irregularities?
The defense is fighting back: During the court hearing, strong criticism was directed towards the sole veterinary report presented in the case, questioning the accuracy of determining age based on teeth examination.
Lawyers denounced what they perceive as bias and an animal rights ideology driving the case.
One of the defendants expressed feeling unfairly targeted, believing the profession was being unfairly vilified.
Of all the implicated establishments, only one is still operating, conducting business exclusively with French breeders. However, operations are less lucrative due to the 2024 law prohibiting pet shops from displaying animals in shop windows.
Sales are now primarily conducted online, based on the click-and-collect principle…
